Why Django's model.save() Doesn't Call full_clean() and What You Can Do About It
The Reason Behind the Separation
There are two primary reasons why Django separates save()
and full_clean()
:
Flexibility: Separating these methods allows for more granular control over the validation process. Here are some scenarios where this flexibility is useful:
- Customizing Validation Logic: You might have specific validation requirements that go beyond what Django's built-in field-level validation can handle.
full_clean()
provides a place to implement these custom checks. - Partial Updates: If you're only updating a subset of a model's fields, you might not need to perform full validation. You can choose to call
full_clean()
only when necessary. - Interaction with Signals: Django signals like
pre_save
andpost_save
allow you to modify data or perform actions before or after saving. These signals can be used in conjunction with manualfull_clean()
calls to fine-tune the validation process.
- Customizing Validation Logic: You might have specific validation requirements that go beyond what Django's built-in field-level validation can handle.
Manually Calling full_clean()
Since save()
doesn't automatically trigger cleaning, you'll need to call full_clean()
explicitly if you want to validate your model data before saving:
my_model_instance = MyModel()
my_model_instance.full_clean() # Perform validation
my_model_instance.save() # Save the data if validation passes
Alternative Approaches
- ModelForms: When using Django ModelForms, the form automatically performs cleaning and validation before saving the data. This is a convenient approach when handling user input through forms.
- Custom Save Methods: You can override the
save()
method in your model to include a call tofull_clean()
. This approach can be useful for more complex validation scenarios.
Key Points to Remember
model.save()
prioritizes backwards compatibility and flexibility by not automatically callingfull_clean()
.- For explicit validation before saving, manually call
full_clean()
. - ModelForms and custom
save()
methods offer alternative ways to handle validation.
By understanding this separation and the reasons behind it, you can effectively manage data validation in your Django models.
Example Codes:
Manual full_clean() before save():
class MyModel(models.Model):
name = models.CharField(max_length=100)
email = models.EmailField(unique=True)
def clean(self):
# Custom validation logic, e.g., checking for specific name formats
if len(self.name) < 5:
raise ValidationError("Name must be at least 5 characters long.")
return super().clean()
def save(self, *args, **kwargs):
self.full_clean() # Explicit validation call
super().save(*args, **kwargs) # Save if validation passes
Using ModelForms:
from django import forms
class MyModelForm(forms.ModelForm):
class Meta:
model = MyModel
fields = '__all__'
def create_model_with_form(data):
form = MyModelForm(data)
if form.is_valid():
form.save()
# Model is saved after form validation
else:
print(form.errors) # Handle form validation errors
Custom save() Method:
class MyModel(models.Model):
name = models.CharField(max_length=100)
email = models.EmailField(unique=True)
def clean(self):
# Custom validation logic
return super().clean()
def save(self, *args, **kwargs):
self.full_clean() # Explicit validation call
super().save(*args, **kwargs) # Save if validation passes
These examples illustrate how you can achieve validation in your Django models using different methods:
- Manual full_clean(): Offers granular control but requires explicit calls.
- ModelForms: Convenient for user input validation but might not be suitable for all scenarios.
- Custom save() Method: Provides flexibility but can lead to code duplication if used across multiple models.
Choose the approach that best suits your specific validation needs and project structure.
Validators on Field Definitions:
Django provides built-in validators that you can directly attach to model fields. These validators perform basic checks like ensuring minimum/maximum length, checking for specific values, or validating email formats.
from django.core.validators import MinLengthValidator, MaxLengthValidator, EmailValidator
class MyModel(models.Model):
name = models.CharField(max_length=100, validators=[MinLengthValidator(5)])
email = models.EmailField(validators=[EmailValidator()])
This approach is efficient for simple validations but might not be suitable for complex logic.
Custom Validators:
You can create your own custom validators that take the field value as input and raise a ValidationError
if the validation fails. This allows for more intricate validation logic.
from django.core.exceptions import ValidationError
def validate_phone_number(value):
# Regex or custom logic to validate phone number format
if not value.isdigit():
raise ValidationError("Phone number must contain only digits.")
class MyModel(models.Model):
phone_number = models.CharField(max_length=15, validators=[validate_phone_number])
Signals:
Django provides signals like pre_save
and post_save
that are triggered before and after saving a model instance. You can connect functions to these signals to perform additional validation or data manipulation.
from django.db.models.signals import pre_save
def validate_unique_combination(sender, instance, **kwargs):
# Custom logic to check if a combination of fields is unique
# (e.g., name and email combination)
if MyModel.objects.filter(name=instance.name, email=instance.email).exists():
raise ValidationError("This combination of name and email already exists.")
pre_save.connect(validate_unique_combination, sender=MyModel)
Third-Party Libraries:
Several third-party libraries like django-validation
and django-crispy-forms
offer advanced validation features and functionalities that can extend Django's built-in validation capabilities. Consider exploring these options for specific validation needs.
By combining these techniques, you can create a robust validation system for your Django models that caters to simple and complex validation scenarios. The choice of method depends on the level of complexity and the specific validation requirements you have.
python django django-models